My question is that shia believe that umar burnt the door of Syeda tun Nisa SalamUllahi Alaye haa.The question is that why are then there so much ambiguities in the traditions of this story?Where was Imam Ali alaye hi salam and where were Hassnain e Kreemain alayehimassalam ? Also,is'nt it an insult of Syeda to say that she was replying umar from inside her house,while Ali alaye hi salam,Zubair and others were inside house? It is narrated that a child named Muhassan was miscarried.The question also arises that how come the child was named before his birth? And why did'nt Imam Ali alaye hi salam take revenge of this violence?as the will of keeping patience (according to shia) was about the injustice to Imam Ali alaye hi salam and not to Syeda Salam Ullahi alaye ha and as shia narrations show that Ali alaye hi salam became furious when abu bakr and umar came to search for the grave of Syeda,why did'nt he become furious when such a violence was done on Syeda?
Rasool e Pak ki Rehlat k bad jab Mola Ali and kuch sahaba jo kh rasool pak k Ghusal and tadfeen ma busy thy to kuch log jin ko hakoomat ka lalach tha unhon khud sy faisla kr k abu bakar ko khaleefa bana liya, And jab BB Syeda k darwazy pr gay wo is liy gay thy kh Hazrat e ALI sy abu bakar bait lena chahta tha but aik IMAM kisi dusry ki kis tarah bait kr sakta ha. us waqat MOLA ALI ghr pr hi thy. But BB pak ny Hazrat e Ali sy kaha kh shaid ya muslman Rasool ki beti ka kuch lehaz kr lain is liy unhon ny hazrat e Ali ko agy nahi kiya. Lakin jo sahaba jo kh asal ma lanti hain unhon ny BB pak ka Lehaz b nai kiya and darwazy ko ag laga di or pher us darwazy ko BB pak pr gira diya. and Hazarat E ALI ko galy ma rassiyan dal kr ghr sy ghaset,ty huy ghr sy ly gay. Hazrat Imam e Hassan and Hussain us waqt choty thy. 2, Jis tarah Hazrat e Hassan and Hussain k Name Jibrail ly k ay thy and hazrat e MUHAMMED PBUH ny ya name rakhy thy esi tarh Hazrat Mohsin jo shaheed huy thy un ka name b rakha gya tha. Ya name duniya ma phly kabhi b nai rakhy gy thy. 3, Hazrat e ALI ny jab b talwar uthai Islam k liy uthai. Agr Mola ALI abubakar and umer k khilaf jihad krty ya talwar uthaty to log khty kh Mola ALI hakoomat k liy larty rhy hn. Mola ALI ko hakomat ki zaroorat nai thi. Wo hamesha ISLAM ki baqa k liy jihad krty rhy.jab k umer and abubakar ny jitni b hakomat ki ha wo talwar k zoor pr ki ha. 4, BB pak ny wasiat ki thi kh meri qabar ka nishan khatam kr diya jay. or janazy ma sirf salman farsi, qambar, Imam Hassan, Hussain, Mola ALI and kuch or log shamil thy. Jin ko rasool ki beti ki IZAT ka pata tha. And bb ki wasiat thi kh jin sy main narat hun un ko mery janazy ma shamil na hony diya jay.
Janb 1 Jawab daleel see den. Mohammad pbuh ko jabrail alesalam sab khuch Bata dete thye khuda k hukam see ye kaise ho sakta hai k in sahaba Jo k 24 hour un k sath the lekin un k dill aap or aap k ahle bait k sath nahe thye .un k bare m aap pubh ko kiun nahe batia gia is m Kiya maslehat thee .Allah or us k rasool k taraf se
I ask all shia's if hazrat Ali R.A. was appointed imam/khalifa by prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) then why did he wait to become the 4th khalifa. what was he doing all these years to become the 4th khalifa. If he was the chosen one by Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) then he went against prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) will. He was suppose to do jihad to do justice to get khilafat as per Prophets Muhammad's (p.b.u.h) will. Plus if Ahlul bait hated Umar , abu bakr, usman (May Allah be please with them) then we can see the family tree of Ahlul bait keeping names such as umar, abubakr, usman for their childrens. plus they even married their children within the families of Abubakr, umar & usman (may Allah be please with them all) proving that some stories between the relationship of Ahlulbait and the 3 caliphs might be fabricated.
Mola Ali ny Wait is liy kiya kun kh Mola ALI ko hakomat ka lalach nai tha. Kun k Mola ALI wesy b tableeg e Islam krty thy thy. Rasool E Pak ki will k against muslman huy thy jinhon ny Raool e Pak ki will ko jhutlaya tha.
I forgot to mention one more thing here. My last point where i mentioned about AhlulBait keeping names of their children as Abubakr, umar,usman, was because i see that shias don't keep these names because they hate these names. If Ahlul bait had hatred from them then why did they kept these names. Is today's shia community greater than Ahlul Bait, and then the shia claim they love Ahlul bait. That means Ahlul Bait loved Abubakr, Umar and Usman, bus shia's done love the people whom Ahlul Bait loved and whom Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) also loved (i am saying this with proof)
Shia Question and Answers, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of the Shia community. Our mission is to break down and clarify the misunderstood and misinterpreted issues of the Shia school of thought and practice. http://safeer-e-aza.net/answers/index.php
janab aapse guzarish hai ki aap shia ladka koi gair mazhab ki ladki se shadi kar sakta hai agar vo ladki humari qoum me intrested or apnana chahti hai to pls mujhe iska jawab de
Koi ashkal nai hai, albatah koi shia ladki kisi ghair shia se shadi nai ker sakti hai, chahy wo syed he kiyun na ho, ladki ki shadi k liay shia hona zarori hai,
Assalam Oo Alaikum Jee Sis Me Ny Iskay Baray Me Jo Parha Uskay Mutabiq Dono Jaiez Hain Lekin Islam Me Aisay Sab Topics Par Kuch Rules And Regulations Hotay ( Ahtiyati Tadabeer K Tor Par Jo Use Hotay ) According To Imam Khamenei jin Ki Me Taqleed Kar Rha Unkay Mutabiq Aik Syed Mard Gaer Syed Aurat sy Shadi Kar Sakta Islam Me Jaiz Haii R Syeda Bhii Gaer Syed K Sath Kar Saktii Lekin Iski Kush Conditons Hotii Agar Wo Puri Ho To Kisi Qisam Ka Darr Naii hota R Shadi Bhii Jaiz Ho jatii ��
Yahan py Questions krna Or phr Amswers krna, mere khiyal sy ye sahi nai hoga like questn krny waly ko zaruri nai k ilm bohot ho or answer dyny wala bhi zaruri nai k Aalim ho, Kisi sawal k jawab me thori se bhi baat idhr ho jany sy bohot si mushkilat ho skti hai albata kisi Majlis ya Kisi Aalim sy sawalat o jawabat key jaye ta k har kisi ki ghalat fehmia or pareshaniya duur ho. Stay Blessed. :)
salam Sayed my friend sked me about Marriage of Um-e-Kulsom bint Ali a.s with Umer ibn khitab. i told him that this story is false then he showed me rawayat from Al-kaafi. i have attached here below. please help me to understand what is truth.
ضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ هِشَام بْنِ سَالِم عَنْ مدِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنِ الْحُسَيْنِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ عَنِ الن مدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى وَ غَيْرُهُ عَنْ أحَْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَ مُحَ أوَْ حَيْثُ شَاءَتْ قَالَ بَلَى حَيْثُ فِي بَيْتِ زَوْجِهَا تَعْتَد يَ زَوْجُهَا أيَْنَ تَعْتَد هِ ع عَنِ امْرَأةٍَ تُوُف سُلَيْمَانَ بْنِ خَالِدٍ قَالَ سَألَْتُ أبََا عَبْدِ الل م كلُْثُوم فَأخََذَ بِيَدِهَا فَانْطَلَقَ بِهَا إلَِى بَيْتِهِ ما مَاتَ عُمَرُ أتََى أُ ن عَلِيّا ع لَ م قَالَ إِ شَاءَتْ ثُ From Sulaymaan bin Khaalid he said: “I asked Abaa `Abd Allaah ( عليه السلام ) about a woman whose husband dies, where should she do her `iddah, in the house of her husband, or wherever she wants? He (عليه السلام) said: “Yes, wherever she wants”, then he ( عليه السلام ) said: “That `Alee ( عليه السلام ) brought Umm Kulthoom to his home when she became free, when `Umar died” Source: 1. Al-Kulayni, Al-Kaafi, vol. 6, pg. 115, hadeeth # 1
Salam everyone. Ya Ali Madad. Aik sawal poochna chchta hoon k aj kl boht sari earning sites hain jis tarha aj kl bitcoin boht mashoor ha to us ki earning k liay aik website opemn hoi ha jis me gambling or dice jisay lafz istamal kiye gaye hain jabke us me is tarha ka koi kam nahi hota or in sites me invesment b karni parti hai...." So kindly ap me se koi muge ye bta skta ha k is jisay kisi earning source se earn krna sahi ho ga ya nahi... Thanks
My question is ager nikkah ke bad kisi aur se dosti hjae n woh acha lagne lage dosri taraf jis se apka nikkha hua ha woh log lalchi n ajeeb se hu apko har waqt zalil aur khuwar ke ilawa kuch na karen n izzat na jaren n ye banda buhat zaida pyar kare n isse physical relation hjae tou kya karna chahie
Salaam I am facing a very difficult situation at my job... there is a Quran learning class at my job but all are antishia..they say very bad things about Shia and regard them as mushrik yahudy.. should I be continuing my class with them or not?
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteOnline kaise training len
DeleteOnline kaise training len
DeleteMy question is that shia believe that umar burnt the door of Syeda tun Nisa SalamUllahi Alaye haa.The question is that why are then there so much ambiguities in the traditions of this story?Where was Imam Ali alaye hi salam and where were Hassnain e Kreemain alayehimassalam ? Also,is'nt it an insult of Syeda to say that she was replying umar from inside her house,while Ali alaye hi salam,Zubair and others were inside house?
ReplyDeleteIt is narrated that a child named Muhassan was miscarried.The question also arises that how come the child was named before his birth?
And why did'nt Imam Ali alaye hi salam take revenge of this violence?as the will of keeping patience (according to shia) was about the injustice to Imam Ali alaye hi salam and not to Syeda Salam Ullahi alaye ha and as shia narrations show that Ali alaye hi salam became furious when abu bakr and umar came to search for the grave of Syeda,why did'nt he become furious when such a violence was done on Syeda?
Kindly answer these questions.
Rasool e Pak ki Rehlat k bad jab Mola Ali and kuch sahaba jo kh rasool pak k Ghusal and tadfeen ma busy thy to kuch log jin ko hakoomat ka lalach tha unhon khud sy faisla kr k abu bakar ko khaleefa bana liya,
DeleteAnd jab BB Syeda k darwazy pr gay wo is liy gay thy kh Hazrat e ALI sy abu bakar bait lena chahta tha but aik IMAM kisi dusry ki kis tarah bait kr sakta ha. us waqat MOLA ALI ghr pr hi thy. But BB pak ny Hazrat e Ali sy kaha kh shaid ya muslman Rasool ki beti ka kuch lehaz kr lain is liy unhon ny hazrat e Ali ko agy nahi kiya. Lakin jo sahaba jo kh asal ma lanti hain unhon ny BB pak ka Lehaz b nai kiya and darwazy ko ag laga di or pher us darwazy ko BB pak pr gira diya. and Hazarat E ALI ko galy ma rassiyan dal kr ghr sy ghaset,ty huy ghr sy ly gay. Hazrat Imam e Hassan and Hussain us waqt choty thy.
2, Jis tarah Hazrat e Hassan and Hussain k Name Jibrail ly k ay thy and hazrat e MUHAMMED PBUH ny ya name rakhy thy esi tarh Hazrat Mohsin jo shaheed huy thy un ka name b rakha gya tha. Ya name duniya ma phly kabhi b nai rakhy gy thy.
3, Hazrat e ALI ny jab b talwar uthai Islam k liy uthai. Agr Mola ALI abubakar and umer k khilaf jihad krty ya talwar uthaty to log khty kh Mola ALI hakoomat k liy larty rhy hn. Mola ALI ko hakomat ki zaroorat nai thi. Wo hamesha ISLAM ki baqa k liy jihad krty rhy.jab k umer and abubakar ny jitni b hakomat ki ha wo talwar k zoor pr ki ha.
4, BB pak ny wasiat ki thi kh meri qabar ka nishan khatam kr diya jay. or janazy ma sirf salman farsi, qambar, Imam Hassan, Hussain, Mola ALI and kuch or log shamil thy. Jin ko rasool ki beti ki IZAT ka pata tha. And bb ki wasiat thi kh jin sy main narat hun un ko mery janazy ma shamil na hony diya jay.
Masha Allah very nice answer
DeleteThanks for your answer. Khuad aap ko khush rakhe.
DeleteJanb 1 Jawab daleel see den. Mohammad pbuh ko jabrail alesalam sab khuch Bata dete thye khuda k hukam see ye kaise ho sakta hai k in sahaba Jo k 24 hour un k sath the lekin un k dill aap or aap k ahle bait k sath nahe thye .un k bare m aap pubh ko kiun nahe batia gia is m Kiya maslehat thee .Allah or us k rasool k taraf se
DeleteI ask all shia's if hazrat Ali R.A. was appointed imam/khalifa by prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) then why did he wait to become the 4th khalifa.
ReplyDeletewhat was he doing all these years to become the 4th khalifa.
If he was the chosen one by Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) then he went against prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) will.
He was suppose to do jihad to do justice to get khilafat as per Prophets Muhammad's (p.b.u.h) will.
Plus if Ahlul bait hated Umar , abu bakr, usman (May Allah be please with them) then we can see the family tree of Ahlul bait keeping names such as umar, abubakr, usman for their childrens. plus they even married their children within the families of Abubakr, umar & usman (may Allah be please with them all) proving that some stories between the relationship of Ahlulbait and the 3 caliphs might be fabricated.
Is sawal se pahly me tum se ek sawal kerta hon? kia islam me siyasat jahiz hai k na jahiz?
DeleteMola Ali ny Wait is liy kiya kun kh Mola ALI ko hakomat ka lalach nai tha. Kun k Mola ALI wesy b tableeg e Islam krty thy thy.
DeleteRasool E Pak ki will k against muslman huy thy jinhon ny Raool e Pak ki will ko jhutlaya tha.
I forgot to mention one more thing here.
ReplyDeleteMy last point where i mentioned about AhlulBait keeping names of their children as Abubakr, umar,usman, was because i see that shias don't keep these names because they hate these names.
If Ahlul bait had hatred from them then why did they kept these names. Is today's shia community greater than Ahlul Bait, and then the shia claim they love Ahlul bait. That means Ahlul Bait loved Abubakr, Umar and Usman, bus shia's done love the people whom Ahlul Bait loved and whom Prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) also loved (i am saying this with proof)
Please mention, Kh AHLE BAIT ny apny kon sy bachon k name usman, abubakar yar usman rakha?
DeleteSalam
ReplyDeleteYa ALI a.s madad
Janab aapse guzarish hai k aap koi new questions b add kren plzz..
Shia Question and Answers, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of the Shia community. Our mission is to break down and clarify the misunderstood and misinterpreted issues of the Shia school of thought and practice.
ReplyDeletehttp://safeer-e-aza.net/answers/index.php
janab aapse guzarish hai ki aap shia ladka koi gair mazhab ki ladki se shadi kar sakta hai agar vo ladki humari qoum me intrested or apnana chahti hai to pls mujhe iska jawab de
ReplyDeleteKoi ashkal nai hai, albatah koi shia ladki kisi ghair shia se shadi nai ker sakti hai, chahy wo syed he kiyun na ho, ladki ki shadi k liay shia hona zarori hai,
Deletei have to imprtnt questions...
ReplyDelete1,i need to prove a friend that looking At IMAM ALI A.S is IBADAT
2,saying ALI is also a IBADAT.
Hadees Ha rasool e Pak ki. Kh Hazart e ALI ki tarf dekhna abadat ha.
Deletema ya pochna chahti hn ka kia aik syedazada kisi ghair syed lrki sa shadi kr skta ha? or aik syedzadi kisi ghair syed lrka sa shadi kr skti ha???
ReplyDeleteAssalam Oo Alaikum
DeleteJee Sis Me Ny Iskay Baray Me Jo Parha Uskay Mutabiq Dono Jaiez Hain Lekin Islam Me Aisay Sab Topics Par Kuch Rules And Regulations Hotay ( Ahtiyati Tadabeer K Tor Par Jo Use Hotay ) According To Imam Khamenei jin Ki Me Taqleed Kar Rha Unkay Mutabiq Aik Syed Mard Gaer Syed Aurat sy Shadi Kar Sakta Islam Me Jaiz Haii
R Syeda Bhii Gaer Syed K Sath Kar Saktii Lekin Iski Kush Conditons Hotii Agar Wo Puri Ho To Kisi Qisam Ka Darr Naii hota R Shadi Bhii Jaiz Ho jatii ��
Yahan py Questions krna Or phr Amswers krna, mere khiyal sy ye sahi nai hoga like questn krny waly ko zaruri nai k ilm bohot ho or answer dyny wala bhi zaruri nai k Aalim ho, Kisi sawal k jawab me thori se bhi baat idhr ho jany sy bohot si mushkilat ho skti hai albata kisi Majlis ya Kisi Aalim sy sawalat o jawabat key jaye ta k har kisi ki ghalat fehmia or pareshaniya duur ho.
ReplyDeleteStay Blessed. :)
Q) Allah nay insan ko matte say hi q paida kia
ReplyDeleteQ) Allah nay insan ko matte say hi q paida kia
ReplyDeletesalam Sayed
ReplyDeletemy friend sked me about Marriage of Um-e-Kulsom bint Ali a.s with Umer ibn khitab. i told him that this story is false then he showed me rawayat from Al-kaafi. i have attached here below. please help me to understand what is truth.
ضْرِ بْنِ سُوَيْدٍ عَنْ هِشَام بْنِ سَالِم عَنْ مدِ بْنِ عِيسَى عَنِ الْحُسَيْنِ بْنِ سَعِيدٍ عَنِ الن مدُ بْنُ يَحْيَى وَ غَيْرُهُ عَنْ أحَْمَدَ بْنِ مُحَ مُحَ
أوَْ حَيْثُ شَاءَتْ قَالَ بَلَى حَيْثُ فِي بَيْتِ زَوْجِهَا تَعْتَد يَ زَوْجُهَا أيَْنَ تَعْتَد هِ ع عَنِ امْرَأةٍَ تُوُف سُلَيْمَانَ بْنِ خَالِدٍ قَالَ سَألَْتُ أبََا عَبْدِ الل
م كلُْثُوم فَأخََذَ بِيَدِهَا فَانْطَلَقَ بِهَا إلَِى بَيْتِهِ ما مَاتَ عُمَرُ أتََى أُ ن عَلِيّا ع لَ م قَالَ إِ شَاءَتْ ثُ
From Sulaymaan bin Khaalid he said: “I asked Abaa `Abd Allaah ( عليه السلام ) about a woman whose husband dies, where should she do her `iddah, in the house of her husband, or wherever she wants? He (عليه السلام)
said: “Yes, wherever she wants”, then he ( عليه السلام ) said: “That `Alee ( عليه السلام ) brought Umm Kulthoom to his home when she became free, when `Umar died”
Source:
1. Al-Kulayni, Al-Kaafi, vol. 6, pg. 115, hadeeth # 1
Salam everyone.
ReplyDeleteYa Ali Madad.
Aik sawal poochna chchta hoon k aj kl boht sari earning sites hain jis tarha aj kl bitcoin boht mashoor ha to us ki earning k liay aik website opemn hoi ha jis me gambling or dice jisay lafz istamal kiye gaye hain jabke us me is tarha ka koi kam nahi hota or in sites me invesment b karni parti hai...."
So kindly ap me se koi muge ye bta skta ha k is jisay kisi earning source se earn krna sahi ho ga ya nahi...
Thanks
I want to ask a question:where are the heads of IMAM Hussain a.s and other shohda e Karbala right now?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAssalam Oo Alaikum!
ReplyDeleteDear Brother's And Sisters i have a little confusion that why our fiqah is known as Fiqah-e-Jafferia 🙄🤔
My question is that.. Fidk garden was bestowed to holy prophet saw as fay or as booty?
ReplyDeleteMy question is that.. Fidk garden was bestowed to holy prophet saw as fay or as booty?
ReplyDeleteMy question is ager nikkah ke bad kisi aur se dosti hjae n woh acha lagne lage dosri taraf jis se apka nikkha hua ha woh log lalchi n ajeeb se hu apko har waqt zalil aur khuwar ke ilawa kuch na karen n izzat na jaren n ye banda buhat zaida pyar kare n isse physical relation hjae tou kya karna chahie
ReplyDeletesalam can u tell me some wazifa for weaning my baby off breastfeeding ... thanku
ReplyDeleteSalaam I am facing a very difficult situation at my job... there is a Quran learning class at my job but all are antishia..they say very bad things about Shia and regard them as mushrik yahudy.. should I be continuing my class with them or not?
ReplyDeleteAgar koi shabe ashura inteqal kar jaye tou is ki tadfeen se relete kia hukum hai..??
ReplyDeleteShia naheen kahty saree kitaboon sahasata men likha howa hy Jo PARHO
ReplyDelete